Pop, bam, fizz! Another New Year arrives, with fresh round of wild ideas from EDGE.org.
“What will change everything?” was John Brockman’s question this year. “What game-changing scientific ideas and developments do you expect to live to see?” He’s now posting responses given by more than 150 wide-angle guessers — people from actor Alan Alda to quantum teleportationist Anton Zeilinger — with Frank Wilczek and Betsy Devine filing separate guesses.
“Homesteading in Hilbert space,” predicts Frank Wilczek:
…The quantum world is a New New World far more alien and difficult of access than Columbus’ Old New World. It is also, in a real sense, much bigger… Our fundamental equations do not live in the three-dimensional space of classical physics, but in an (effectively) infinite-dimensional space: Hilbert space. It will take us much more than a century to homestead that New New World, even at today’s much-accelerated pace…
“Happiness,” counter-predicts Betsy Devine:
In the next five years, policy-makers around the world will embrace economic theories (e.g. those of Richard Layard) aimed at creating happiness. The Tower of Economic Babble is rubble. Long live the new, improved happiness economics! …
Here are other short samples from just a few more of the best:
- “The robotic moment” says Sherry Turkle
- I will see the development of robots that people will want to spend time with. Not just a little time, time in which the robots serve as amusements, but enough time and with enough interactivity that the robots will be experienced as companions, each closer to a someone than a something. I think of this as the robotic moment…
- “A forebrain for the world mind” says Danny Hillis
- …If there is such a thing as a world mind today, then its thoughts are primarily about commerce. It is the “invisible hand” of Adam Smith, deciding the prices, allocating the capital…I call this the hindbrain because it is performing unconscious functions necessary to the organism’s own survival, functions that are so primitive that they predate development of the brain. Included in this hindbrain are the functions of preference and attention that create celebrity, popularity and fashion, all fundamental to the operation of human society. This hindbrain is ancient….
- “Molecular manufacturing” says Ed Regis
- …Program the assemblers to put together an SUV, a sailboat, or a spacecraft, and they’d do it—automatically, and without human aid or intervention. Further, they’d do it using cheap, readily-available feedstock molecules as raw materials. The idea sounds fatuous in the extreme…until you remember that objects as big and complex as whales, dinosaurs, and sumo wrestlers got built in a moderately analogous fashion…
- “We are learning to make phenotypes” says Mark Pagel
- …the thing that we think of as “us”,can become separated from our body, or nearly separated anyway. I don’t suggest we will be able to transplant our mind to another body, but we will be able to introduce new body parts into existing bodies with a resident mind. With enough such replacements, we will become potentially immortal: like ancient buildings that exist only because over the centuries each of their many stones has been replaced…
- “Malthusian information famine” says Charles Seife
- …There seems to be a Malthusian principle at work: information grows exponentially, but useful information grows only linearly. Noise will drown out signal. The moment that we, as a species, finally have the memory to store our every thought, etch our every experience into a digital medium, it will be hard to avoid slipping into a Borgesian nightmare where we are engulfed by our own mental refuse…
- “The use of nuclear weapons against a civilian population” says Lawrence Krauss
- …Having been forced to choose a single game changer, I have turned away from the fascinating scientific developments I might like to see, and will instead focus on the one game changer that I will hopefully never directly witness, but nevertheless expect will occur during my lifetime: the use of nuclear weapons against a civilian population…
I join Lawrence in hoping that his prediction won’t come true.

2 responses so far ↓
1 TA // Jan 14, 2009 at 11:28 am
That may well have been this year’s largest time sink, but I finally made it through all entries. Rather subdued compared to previous years. Nothing as spunky as this. Probably a sign of the times. Plenty of baby boomers calling for mind uploading (though they keep saying “downloading”, don’t ask me why), bioengineered immortality or at least affordable cryogenic freezing (an interesting idea, that: pay to volunteer as guinea pig for future restoration technologies, look forward to a really interesting awakening) and the odd call for even higher taxes to make somebody else finance it all. ;)
No need to disguise that as a “scientific” idea, I’m sure the world will keep running according to script anyway.
Me, I’ll be listening to the signature song of my generation while I wait for the lights to go out.
2 TA // Jan 14, 2009 at 11:32 am
P.S. The spunky entry from 2007 which I thought I linked to but apparently didn’t is http://edge.org/q2007/q07_15.html#golomb